“IN PANDEMIC FIGHT, PUBLIC TRANSIT IS PART OF THE SOLUTION, NOT THE PROBLEM”

Written by William C. Vantuono, Editor-in-Chief
image description

OK, I’ll give you one guess as to who said this. Hints: It’s not APTA or the Eno Center for Transportation. It’s not one of the giant public transportation agencies like the New York MTA or NJ Transit or CTA or WMATA or Los Angeles Metro. It’s not one of the huge engineering consulting firms like WSP USA, AECOM or Parsons. It’s not a transit car builder like Alstom, Siemens or Bombardier. It’s not even Contributing Editor David Peter Alan, whose passion for rail transit has generated tens of thousands of words for the Railway Age website. Give up?

It’s one of the leading Wall Street analyst firms in the “rail space,” as our industry is called in Street jargon: Cowen and Company, whose Managing Director, Jason Seidl, is Railway Age’s Wall Street Contributing Editor.

Wall Street embracing climate change and touting public transportation? Has Hell frozen over? Has clearing smog in cities like New York and Los Angeles created by fewer cars on the road resulted in clearer heads and sharper thinking?

The intersections of the 5, 10, 60, and 101 freeways near downtown Los Angeles during what is usually rush hour. (Chava Sanchez/LAist)

As United States Marine Corps Private First Class Gomer Pyle, the lead character played by Jim Nabors in the 1960s TV sitcom Gomer Pyle, U.S.M.C., often said, “Surprise, surprise!”

Well, shucks, Gomer, I ain’t surprised! Dang, makes sense to me!

OK, OK, I’ll get to the point. Cowen and Company analysts Siedl, Matt Elkott (whose specialty is the railway equipment market—namely, freight cars and component suppliers) and Adam Kramer (no connection to CNBC’s excitable, highly animated Jim Cramer)—said that public transit is part of the solution to overcoming COVID-19. Cowen’s context: Wabtec (WAB), whose global business model covers every corner of the rail industry, freight and passenger. I’ll let our guys on The Street tell it. Italicized words are my emphasis:

“Public transit is key in the climate change fight, which is in turn one defense against future pandemics. The potential long-term impact of lower ridership on equipment demand could be offset by social distancing measures. The pursuit of safer service should also lead to more upgrades/replacement. A favorable modal shift cannot be ruled out. We project 8% transit revenue growth for WAB in 2021.

“2020: One Big Step Back on an Otherwise Steady Journey Forward”

“Long viewed as a more stable, albeit less exciting, part of WAB’s business, transit equipment is now in focus. Concerns about the future viability of public transit may have reached levels not seen before. The ease with which this is understandable derives from the difficulty of imagining social distancing on a rush hour train. Ridership is down 90% on some transit systems; and according to a late-April survey by the American Public Transportation Association, of 121 U.S. public transit agencies representing 76% of national ridership, only 17% of respondents said they are running more than 75% of their pre-COVID-19 service levels. This will likely lead to lower spending on equipment. For 2020, we are projecting a 14% decline in transit segment sales for WAB, compared to our estimate of 4% growth before adjusting for coronavirus impacts.

“Longer-Term Transit Equipment Outlook Remains Favorable”

“Beyond 2020, the solid growth outlook for the transit equipment market remains intact and pillared on the following factors:

  1. Public transit is key in the climate change fight: According to the U.S. Department of Transportation, heavy rail transit such as subways and metros produce on average 76% lower greenhouse gas emissions per passenger mile than an average single-occupancy vehicle; light rail systems produce 62% less; and bus transit produces 33% less. Roughly 29% of greenhouse gas emissions is released by the transportation sector.
  2. Climate change is key to curbing pandemics: Deforestation and warming temperatures are increasingly causing species to lose habitat and putting them in closer contact with humans, thus raising the risk of animal-to-human spread of viruses. Being key in the fight against climate change, public transit is one of the defenses against future pandemics.
  3. The potential long-term impact of lower ridership on equipment demand could be offset by social distancing measures: In the aforementioned APTA survey, 60% of responding agencies said they plan to increase service on certain routes to reduce crowding.
  4. Increased equipment upgrades and replacement: According to APTA, transit agencies will rely on manufacturers to design equipment that promotes better air circulation.
  5. Some domestic air travel could go to regional passenger rail. This is as social distancing and maintaining clean air circulation may be somewhat easier to achieve on railroad systems such as Amtrak.

“Wabtec is well-positioned to benefit from a number of long-term trends, including rail automation and transit growth. We view the transformative GE Transportation merger favorably and expect it to be highly accretive in the long term. Valuation looks compelling. We rate WAB Outperform.”

Wabtec Form 5 Knuckle (Tightlock) transit car coupler.

To all the politicians and health care officials who tell us to avoid public transportation, do your homework, learn the facts, and start speaking the truth.

To anyone who believes climate change is a hoax, test your hypothesis by running this experiment: Move to the Arctic or Antarctica or anywhere glaciers exist, and check that the ice is melting. Take a core sample and check for toxic pollutants, and deadly viruses that have been trapped for thousands of years, never encountered before. Let us know of your findings, so that those of us who don’t have our heads buried in the sand can do something to protect ourselves—if we aren’t underwater.

That’s not a political statement, in case you were wondering. It truly troubles me when issues affecting human life and the environment become politicized. The coronavirus doesn’t give a rat’s ass whether you’re a Republican or a Democrat, a conservative, a liberal, or somewhere in between. It doesn’t pay attention to The Illusion of Separation.

Long term, I rate public transportation Outperform. Transit is definitely not the “less exciting” part of Wabtec’s business—not when that business is instrumental to preserving what is written in the Declaration of Independence: “Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness.”

I’ve been noticing more birds in my neighborhood …
Categories: Commuter/Regional, High Performance, Intercity, Light Rail, News, Passenger, Rapid Transit, Regulatory Tags: , , ,